Word Count

Writers Talk About Writing

Wrong Turns: Keeping Readers Off the "Garden Path"

Sentences have destinations, the place you want your readers to go to absorb the information you're delivering. Most are simple: "The City Council voted for a sales tax increase." Some can be complex, but still understandable: "The mayor is expected to ask the City Council to enact a tax increase, an attempt to replace some of the money lost as a result of lower-than-expected property tax revenues."

On occasion, sentences end up confusing readers: "Declaring that property tax revenues had fallen too low, sales taxes are going up as a result of a City Council vote." In this case, a classic dangler, a reader starts thinking "someone" is declaring property tax revenues were too low, but that "someone" is missing. The reader has to back up and rethink what the sentence is trying to say.

Sentences that mislead readers are called "garden path" sentences, because they take readers in unexpected directions, the way someone who has been "led down the garden path" has been misled.

"Garden path" sentences may be grammatically correct. They might occur when a word that can be a noun/adjective or a verb/adverb confuses a reader: "The police report that targets abuse convicts enumerates ways to avoid overloading parole officers." Which of the words in that sentence are intended to be nouns or adjectives and which are intended to be verbs or adverbs? A rewording would make it clear: "A report by police indicates how to lighten the workload of parole officers who work with convicted abusers."

Or the sentence may have a phrase in the wrong place: "This year, Adelson has given at least $10 million, along with his wife, to support Newt Gingrich's presidential campaign." While it's possible that Adelson gave his wife to Gingrich's campaign, the writer probably meant "This year, Adelson and his wife have given $10 million to support Newt Gingrich's campaign."

Sometimes a "garden path sentence" may start in one direction and then switch, throwing off a reader: "The two were taken by police officers to the First Precinct station in separate cars, where they were searched, photographed,and shackled to a table with other prisoners and collaborated to write their story." The sentence starts out describing the experience of an arrest, and then switches focus to "their story," which may or may not have anything to do with the arrest. The phrase "in separate cars" is also slightly misleading, possibly making some readers think "the two" were in separate cars when they were searched, photographed, etc. One fix could be: "The two decided to collaborate on their story after they had been taken in separate cars to the First Precinct station, where they were searched, photographed, and shackled to a table with other prisoners."

Preventing "garden path" sentences is easy, provided you are paying attention to what you are writing. Read your sentence one word or phrase at a time, forming the "path" it is taking in your head. If you find yourself coming to a fork in the road, don't take it. Back up, stop to decide why the roses smell, and stay on the straight and narrow. That way, you can even avoid sentences like that last one, which tortures metaphors and then mixes them.


Rate this article:

Click here to read more articles from Word Count.

Merrill Perlman is adjunct assistant professor at the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism and president of Merrill Perlman Consulting, offering consulting and freelance editing services and training in journalism, grammar and usage. Among her clients are The New York Times, ProPublica and the Poynter Institute. She writes the "Language Corner" column and blog for Columbia Journalism Review. Merrill retired in June 2008 after 25 years at The New York Times, most recently as director of copy desks with responsibility for managing 150 copy editors. Click here to read more articles by Merrill Perlman.

Join the conversation

Comments from our users:

Monday June 23rd, 9:21 AM
Comment by: Westy (Paris, OH)
I would like to hear more about tortured metaphores.
Monday June 23rd, 2:39 PM
Comment by: Kristine F.Top 10 Commenter
In addition to torturing metaphors, that "last sentence" also has a common misspelling: "straight" should be "strait" in that phrase (and also in "strait jacket"). The meanings of the two words are not the same; we all know what "straight" means; strait means narrow, restrictive or confining. So, a strait and narrow way or path could be very curvy and hilly. Interesting, eh? You're welcome!

The misspelling is minuscule - the article is great! I'm so glad to have a name for those convoluted, confusing garden path sentences that can totally derail a concept or message! Thanks, Merrill

The Happy Quibbler
Monday June 23rd, 3:59 PM
Comment by: Richard F. (San Diego, CA)
While I don't mind rereading a sentence that has new meaning for me, I do mind rereading a sentence that is maze-like. In most cases, clarity is a virtue. Years ago I read some writings on "information theory" and was impressed by the issues of "signal" and "noise" in communication, your article reminds me of those issues. Thanks.
Tuesday June 24th, 12:14 AM
Comment by: Nancy FriedmanVisual Thesaurus Contributor
Kristine: Here's World Wide Words, an authority on idioms and usage, on straight and narrow vs. strait and narrow:

"Both have been widely used down the centuries. However, the evidence is that you would have been safe, and indeed better advised, to use straight and narrow for both your British and your US readers."

"Strait jacket," is correct, of course.
Tuesday June 24th, 1:09 AM
Comment by: Kristine F.Top 10 Commenter
Nancy, that's interesting - I stand collected -Thanks!
Tuesday June 24th, 2:54 AM
Comment by: Kip V. (Parker, AZ)
This is perfect timing for me, because I am writing the middle of a class on writing a thesis research paper. And this type of scenario will go great to help out my classmates also. I put in a plug for this website quite often to different classes that I've had what I found that I needed this for various reasons.

I personally want to thank you for the contribution for us to read this as members of this website because who knows why a person might need this information, everyone has their own reason but it's a reason they needed and I'm glad it's there.

Respectfully,

Kip Vidrine
vworkssocali@gmail.com
vworkssocali@email.phoenix.edu

Do you have a comment?

Share it with the Visual Thesaurus community.

Your comments:

Sign in to post a comment!

We're sorry, you must be a subscriber to comment.

Click here to subscribe today.

Already a subscriber? Click here to login.