Word Routes

Exploring the pathways of our lexicon

Googling vs. Bing-ing

When google, a verb meaning "to search the Internet," was chosen by the American Dialect Society as Word of the Decade (2000-09), my ADS colleague Grant Barrett wondered whether Google's trademark lawyers might have preferred it if the runner-up, blog, had won instead. It is of course a tribute to the vast popularity of Google that it has become accepted as a generic verb for online searching, but the protectors of the trademark wouldn't necessarily see it that way. Meanwhile, Microsoft, creators of the rival search engine Bing, would very much like people to use their brand name as a verb.

The very first known appearance of the verb google comes from none other than Google cofounder Larry Page. In an announcement to the Google-Friends list on July 8, 1998, back when Google was a still a search engine on the Stanford University website, Page signed off by saying, "Have fun and keep googling!" Note that even back then in the early days, google in its verb form could be uncapitalized. (Perhaps it still carried a whiff of the word googol, the term for 1 followed by 100 zeros, on which Google was based.)

Of course, when Google was incorporated as a company a few months later, the lawyers got involved and Google was registered as a trademark. Trademark holders are always on the lookout for dilutions of the brand name, which could possibly lead down the slippery slope of genericization. (See Orin Hargraves' Language Lounge from last April for more on the ins and outs of genericization.) Google outlines the proper use of the trademark on its permissions page:

  • Use the trademark only as an adjective, never as a noun or verb, and never in the plural or possessive form.
  • Use a generic term following the trademark, for example: GOOGLE search engine, Google search, GOOGLE web search.

Despite these guidelines, Google (or google) quickly went generic. Paul McFedries of WordSpy was one of the first to document the extended use of the verb, creating an entry for it on his site in April 2001. For his troubles, McFedries was slapped with a cease-and-desist letter from Google in early 2003, which he shared with the American Dialect Society mailing list. Coincidentally, the ADS had just named google the Most Useful Word of 2002 (losing out to WMD in the main Word of the Year category).

By 2006, genericized google had become so common that both Merriam-Webster and the Oxford English Dictionary had published entries for it. Google responded on its official blog with a post that tried to be both light-hearted and legalistic (a tough mix). Grudgingly, they seemed to accept Google as a verb meaning "to search for information on Google," but the more extended use was declared verboten:

Our lawyers say: Bad. Very, very bad. You can only "Google" on the Google search engine. If you absolutely must use one of our competitors, please feel free to "search" on Yahoo or any other search engine.

Fast-forward to May 2009, when Microsoft announced that it was rebranding its Live Search as Bing. (See Nancy Friedman's Candlepower column, "The Bing Bang," for an extended rumination on the brand name.) Bing was registered as a trademark just like Google, but the Microsoft honchos were amenable to verbing right from the start, as reported in the New York Times:

And if Bing turns into a verb like, say, Xerox, TiVo or, well, Google, that would be nice too. Steven A. Ballmer, Microsoft's chief executive, said Thursday that he liked Bing's potential to "verb up."

Now, in 2010, how is the "verbing up" going? Are people Bing-ing, or even bing-ing? (I feel it necessary to insert a hyphen to avoid the impression that the root word is binge.) Last September, Chris Crum of WebProNews said, "Apparently there are people using 'Bing' as a verb, although I haven't really heard this one thrown around in real life yet." The verb still doesn't seem to have broken through into common usage, while google reigns supreme.

I leave you with a spoof commercial from the CollegeHumor website that illustrates just what Bing is up against.


Rate this article:

Click here to read more articles from Word Routes.

Ben Zimmer is executive editor of Vocabulary.com and the Visual Thesaurus. He is language columnist for The Wall Street Journal and former language columnist for The Boston Globe and The New York Times Magazine. He has worked as editor for American dictionaries at Oxford University Press and as a consultant to the Oxford English Dictionary. In addition to his regular "Word Routes" column here, he contributes to the group weblog Language Log. He is also the chair of the New Words Committee of the American Dialect Society. Click here to read more articles by Ben Zimmer.

Join the conversation

Comments from our users:

Friday January 22nd 2010, 8:17 AM
Comment by: Don H. (Antioch, CA)Top 10 Commenter
That was enlightening. Thanks.

I thought the spoof ad was amazing. It is difficult to believe people could invest that much production value in a joke. I wonder if they were just hacking an actual ad.
Friday January 22nd 2010, 9:49 AM
Comment by: Jon D. (King of Prussia, PA)
Fun topic. While I never see a time when we're binging the world wide web, I can see a time when we put googling to rest and move onto more English-y words like searched, checked, found, located, cobbled, unearthed, etc.

That is, unless a new way of finding things on the web is unleashed that changes the very notion of the activity. Imagine, if you will, a time when we get so advanced that we no longer have to search for anything. Instead, things we want or need arrive to us proactively based on advanced profiling, analytics and heuristics.

In this case, we wouldn't be searching, finding, or googling anymore. Though, I can imagine a notification alerting me of new content sounding like...

"Bing! You've got stuff!"
Friday January 22nd 2010, 6:37 PM
Comment by: Katie St. John L.
A fun commerical! A few months ago, I commented on my Facebook page about the Bing search engine enquiring (I am a Brit so apologise for the spelling)how to use this word. I agree with the writer that it would have to be bing-ing (bingeing being something with other connotations). If we can say one googled something, do we now say one binged? Not only is there a problem with writing it; however it is written, the spoken words will still sound as if we have over-indulged in something?
Saturday January 23rd 2010, 2:03 PM
Comment by: Lisa B. (Buffalo, NY)
I remember a similar conflict back in the 1980s when I worked at IBM, and the company chastised its employees not to use the word "xerox"--we were enjoined to use the neutral "photocopy."
Saturday January 23rd 2010, 7:38 PM
Comment by: Don H. (Antioch, CA)Top 10 Commenter
Lisa's story reminded me of a contestant I saw years ago on a talk show. The host asked here who she worked for. I think she said Honeywell. He asked her what they made and she said "Xerox machines." I imagine that got her fired.
Sunday January 24th 2010, 7:11 PM
Comment by: Ellen M.
"Bing-ing" is insufficiently euphonious to push out "googling", which is fun to say and hear (as the spoof demonstrates). I do think lots of people use "search" and related words ("find", "go ask the computer", etc.), but "google" just has that bottom-up mouth appeal.
Sunday January 24th 2010, 8:38 PM
Comment by: nobodyz Susan
Oh my. I just looked up "binger" since I couldn't get the VT to even show binging or bingeing, and you'll never guess what THAT means!

binger = crack addict!

Apparently Microsoft didn't spend much time on the word before adopting it, or at least not before throwing out their wishes that it become a verb.

Do you have a comment?

Share it with the Visual Thesaurus community.

Your comments:

Sign in to post a comment!

We're sorry, you must be a subscriber to comment.

Click here to subscribe today.

Already a subscriber? Click here to login.

The American Dialect Society anoints its picks for the past year and decade.
Grand Theft Motto
- 16 Comments
How trademark holders try to hold on to bits of the language.
The Bing Bang
- 7 Comments
What does "Bing" mean, anyway?