Writers Talk About Writing
When Lightning Strikes, What Does Air Do?
Stan Carey, a professional editor from Ireland, writes entertainingly about the English language on his blog Sentence First. Here a children's book about weather leads Stan to ponder which English words best describe what happens to air when it is heated by lightning.
Burst after burst the innocuous thunders brake.
— Robert Southey
John Farndon's Weather: How to Watch and Understand the Weather and its Changes is a charming children's book published as part of DK's Eyewitness Explorers series. On page 47 I read the following line:
Thunder is the sound of air bursting as it is heated rapidly by lightning.
Some examples will help us examine the semantic constellation of burst. Tomatoes that are bursting with ripeness burst in our hands or in the microwave. A tree's roots burst slowly through concrete; the sun bursts through the clouds; swollen rivers burst their banks; the Hulk's clothes burst at the seams; a sportsman makes a burst of speed to burst through the opposing defence; a busy room fills to bursting (point), whereupon the nearest person to the door might burst it open. The recurring sense of rupture or explosivity is evident in this word map from the Visual Thesaurus:
People burst into song when their hearts are bursting with joy, and they burst into shivers if a window bursts open on a cold day; they burst into tears if their hair bursts into flame, and they burst into laughter (or "burst out laughing") when a burst of amusing data enters their minds. We hear bursts of conversation and bursts of gunfire. We see bursts of activity, such as sudden bursts of rain or sunshine. When air or another gas bursts, it is usually from something, such as a tyre, bubble, balloon, nail gun, or a mouth in the act of blowing out a candle (though a puff is usually enough).
The sound of thunder can be a clap, crack, peal, snap, roll, or rumble; each term has its own nuances. But to explain the sound as air bursting is, I think, inferior to expanding rapidly or some such phrase that would minimise the possibility of fuzzy or misleading interpretations. Especially since many people — not least children — are afraid of storms, and air bursting carries more alarming connotations than does air expanding (slight semantic overlap notwithstanding).
Am I being foolish, fussy, or fair? Have I made a storm in my afternoon teacup?