Word Count

Writers Talk About Writing

Content-Free Prose: Death of Writing or Next Big Thing?

There's a new online threat to writing. Critics of the web like to blame email, texts, and chat for killing prose. Even blogs don't escape their wrath. But in fact the opposite is true: thanks to computers, writing is thriving. More people are writing more than ever, and this new wave of everyone's-an-author bodes well for the future of writing, even if not all that makes its way online is interesting or high in quality.

But two new digital developments, ebook spam and content farms, now threaten the survival of writing as we know it. 

According to the Guardian, growing numbers of "authors" are churning out meaningless ebooks by harvesting sections of text from the web, licensing it for a small fee from online rights aggregators, or copying it for free from an open source like Project Gutenberg. These authors — we could call them text engineers — contribute nothing to the writing process beyond selecting passages to copy and stringing them together, or if that seems too much like work, just cutting out the original author's name and pasting in their own. The spam ebooks that result are composed entirely of prose designed, not to convey information or send a message, but to churn profits.

The other new source of empty text is content farms, Internet sweatshops where part-timers generate prose whose sole purpose is to use keywords that attract the attention of search engines. The goal of content farms is not to get relevant text in front of you, but to get you to view the paid advertising in which the otherwise meaningless words are nested.

Ebook spam and content farms may sound like the antitheses of traditional writing, in that they don't inform, stimulate thought, or comment on the human condition. They're certainly not the kind of repurposed writing that Wired Magazine's Kevin Kelly foresaw back in 2006 when he wrote that we'd soon be doing with online prose what we were already doing with music: sampling, copying, remixing, and mashing up other people's words to create our own personal textual playlists.

Kelly, who was paid for his essay, also predicted that in the brave new world of digital text the value we once assigned to words would shift to links, tags, and annotations, and that authors, no longer be paid for producing content, would once again become amateurs motivated by the burning need to share, as they now do with such abandon on Facebook and Twitter.

But if we mash up Kelly's futuristic vision with the harsh reality that strings of keywords may bring in more dollars than connected prose, then it's possible that tomorrow's writers won't be bloggers, Tweeters, or even taggers; they'll be scrapbookers, motivated by the burning need to cut and paste. The web may be making authors of us all, but the growing number of content-free links threatens to put writing as we know it out of business.

A cynic might argue that far too many writers have already mastered the art of saying absolutely nothing, so we shouldn't be surprised if our feverish quest to capitalize on the Internet, combined with the vast expansion of the author pool that the net makes possible, have created the monster of contentless prose. We get the writing we deserve.

Plus, things online having the attraction that they do, instead of damning these new genres, soon we may be teaching students how to master them. After all, no writing course is considered complete without a unit on how to write effective email. So it won't be long before some start-up offers a course in text-mashing instaprose. Or an app. I can just see the copy now:

Forget about the five-paragraph theme, the inverted pyramid, and write-revise-publish. The Digital Writers School has a foolproof formula for the digital age: cut, paste, upload. It may not get you a Pulitzer or the Mann Booker, but if you give up the search for the right word and learn instead to game the search algorithm, you could find your writing bringing in a lot of cash per click. No experience necessary! Text today for a free online talent test.

It may seem paradoxical to make money by selling something that is meaningless, but it turns out that today's most-successful marketing is based on this very paradox. So content-free prose will either be the death of writing, or the next big thing.

Rate this article:

Click here to read more articles from Word Count.

Dennis Baron is professor of English and linguistics at the University of Illinois and writes regularly on linguistic issues at The Web of Language. He is the author of A Better Pencil: Readers, Writers, and the Digital Revolution. You can follow him on Twitter @DrGrammar. Click here to read more articles by Dennis Baron.

Join the conversation

Comments from our users:

Wednesday June 29th 2011, 9:38 AM
Comment by: Morse W. (Huntsville, AL)
I disagree. Content free writing is neither the death of writing nor the next big thing. It is just another attempt to fool a search engine's ranking algorithm. I have come across a few of these content free pages, and just find them annoying. I certainly would never buy anything advertised on such a page since the page itself implies the product is worthless. My experience with Google leads me to believe that their algorithms are smart enough to stay ahead of these “authors.”
Wednesday June 29th 2011, 12:03 PM
Comment by: keith M. (Kula, HI)
Thanks to Dr. Grammar for the cutting edge erudition. I appreciate learning about "content farms." I also like his general tone of being open to the new, yet aware of the materialistic machinations around the corner.

I look forward to checking out "The Web of Language."

One final thought in the form of a serious question. Among my colleagues in the Waldorf school movement, I am referred to as a "grammar grouch" partly because I have not given up on noting the proper distinctions and usage of the verbs "lie" (to recline) and "lay" (to place). In the evolution of language, do you think it too late to re-educate others or should pedants like me "lie in the dust" and resign ourselves to other concerns?

keith M.
Wednesday June 29th 2011, 6:46 PM
Comment by: Michael Lydon (New York, NY)Visual Thesaurus Contributor
I love the expression "content farm"! That's where editors milk content cows, where they plant ten acres in meaningless verbiage and another ten in vapid cliches, where they make hay-perboles in the pun shine and can corny jokes in the fall. And when they need fertilizer, they have a never-ending supply of BS!!
Sunday July 3rd 2011, 12:58 PM
Comment by: laura T. (Astoria, OR)
keith, oy! it really depends to whom you are speaking; sometimes it is welcome, sometimes it is not, and i have to ask myself if the content is worth making an overture and getting slapped down. but when eyes roll or i am met with frozen silence, okay, i stop. xoxoxooxox
Sunday July 3rd 2011, 9:24 PM
Comment by: keith M. (Kula, HI)
thanks for the wisdom laura T. discretion remains the better part of valor. if you have anymore grammatical wisdom, i'm open.
i'm not sure it's allowed but you're welcome to email directly to keithmac@hawaii.rr.com
aloha, keith M.
Sunday July 24th 2011, 6:40 PM
Comment by: begum F.Top 10 Commenter
"Content farm" a new addition to our farming job.
Not cut, but copy, paste and then upload.
Invest your talent as fertilizer will then produce a bumper production.
Oh!a little trouble. A new stain of bacteria (ecoli) has been found and w it's growth was bumper also.
Don't worry. You will vanish soon upon consumption of that tainted crop.

Do you have a comment?

Share it with the Visual Thesaurus community.

Your comments:

Sign in to post a comment!

We're sorry, you must be a subscriber to comment.

Click here to subscribe today.

Already a subscriber? Click here to login.

Books by the Numbers
Dennis Baron takes a look at the new science of "culturomics."
"Tweet police" are setting themselves up as guardians of proper language use on Twitter.
A new iPhone app will clean up your text messages.